If you are looking for an actual recipe stop now. I’m still in the experimental stage, but I’m getting closer.
We used to live right next door to Ingles in North Asheville so I often went down for a fresh “dollar muffin”. The muffins were pretty tasty, unlike the rest of the gross baked stuff they sell. Flavors included Blueberry, Pistachio and Cranberry.
We’ve since moved away, so I have to rely more on my own cooking skills.
I’ll get right to the point here. The reason that restaurant and bakery food is so damn good is because you don’t see how much grease and salt they put in. It’s like “Of course I knew that!” but you choose to ignore it. Having worked in the food industry most of my life, I’ve seen first hand what goes into the dishes. I worked at an Italian place once and—no joke—the chef put in one stick of butter in the pan for every cream sauce dish. The clientele raved about how fantastic his food was and he was soon able to charge $20 and $30 per dish.
Once you go online for recipes and start cooking on your own, you’ll find “reasonable recipes” like this one that claim to be ‘The Best Ever Muffin Recipe“. Bull Crap! I made that recipe and the muffins were like small bales of hay. They were dry and nasty tasting. I’m sure that’s what a muffin used to be, but now with the proliferation of bakery muffins, we find ourselves trying to match that awesome taste. Old style muffins were dryer because we used to eat as a family in the 1950’s. You would split the muffin in half and spread butter on top as a kind of ritual. Now people like to “grab and go” with baked goods. When you think of if, bakery muffins are marketed as “Butter already added!“.
What happens at home is that people get so caught up in “watching fat” that they do stupid things like using “no fat butter” or “low fat this” or “fat free that” is some lame effort to diet. Even just following “normal” recipes may not be enough fat for the rich taste you desire. If you’re afraid of fat, then your muffins will stink. In a couple of days, you’ll go to the bakery and buy “one of those really good Ingles muffins” anyway. Its the psychology of “not seeing what goes into the food” that makes us think we can’t cook like a restaurant does.
So for the most beautiful moist and rich muffin in the world, all you do is start with a recipe like this one and then double or triple the fat content. That recipe called for 1/4 cup of oil and I put in 2/3 cup of butter instead. Another trick is to add a small bit of brown sugar. So they call for 3/4 sugar. I put in 1/2 cup sugar and 1/4 cup brown sugar (one of the reasons why Toll House Cookies are so good). Brown sugar or even Molasses naturally adds moisture, but we use them sparingly because the taste is more bitter..
It’s all about the flour to fat ratio.
When you cook baked goods, sooner or later you’ll realize that just about everything is some combination of flour sugar and fat. You’ll also notice that many basic recipes call for around two cups of flour. Use that as a rough ratio. Take a look at the Toll House Cookie recipe and you’ll see a ratio of roughly 2 cups flour to 1 cup fat. That’s the nature of a cookie. They are rich, fatty and low risers. On the other side of the scale, a basic biscuit uses 2 cups of flour to a scant 1/4 cup of fat. The nature of a biscuit is a high riser that is light and flaky. Think of foods you bake as resting somewhere between the richness of a cookie and the flakiness of a biscuit. Ingles muffins really aren’t a muffin at all. They’re a muffin-shaped-cookie!
It seems like a no-brainer for sure, but I see so many people who use things like soy milk and fat free butter and then wonder why their baked goods are so dry. You can’t confuse “moistness” with water. That moist taste is a big gob of fat. Fat free products are just a big bucket of water that has been trapped in a kind of microscopic honeycomb thin film of fat. Once you bake with it, the water evaporates and leaves a hay bale. I actually do use soy milk or almond milk to combat my Asperges, but I always make sure to add more fat to counter the ‘wateriness’ of the product.
Once you understand how fat equals moistness, the rest of a perfect muffin recipe is the art of tossing in small bits of things. I’m still so surprised at how many people are scared to death to variate from a recipe. There is this pent up internal fear of screwing things up. Just start small until you get a feel for things. The batch I made this morning had the extra fat, the shift from white to brown sugar, but then I tossed in 2 squares of crushed Lindt Orange Chocolate, a tablespoon of orange marmalade and a small pealed, diced red apple. Sometimes I’ll toss in a spoon full of peanut butter or even a splash of some kind of liqueur like Kahlúa or Bailies Irish Creme.
———–
Authors Note: If you are a heart surgeon or dairy farmer, please use the donation link as I’m giving you tons of business by writing this.